Introduction

When choosing a gemstone setting, confusion often arises from mixing astrology with jewellery design.
The distinction is simple:

• Astrology → Open setting
• Ornamental jewellery → Closed setting

Both are correct — for different purposes.

Open Setting — Preferred for Astrology

An open setting means:

• The back of the gemstone is open
• The stone touches the skin directly
• No metal barrier between stone and wearer

Why Astrology Prefers Open Settings

In astrological practice, gemstones are worn to support planetary influences.
Direct skin contact is traditionally preferred because it:

• Allows continuous interaction
• Follows classical astrological rules
• Maintains consistency of wear

This is why astrologers recommend open settings for gemstones such as:

• Ruby (Manik)
• Blue Sapphire (Neelam)
• Emerald (Panna)
• Yellow Sapphire (Pukhraj)
• Hessonite (Gomed)
• Cat’s Eye (Lehsunia)

Common forms include open-back rings and pendants touching the skin.

Skin contact is a core astrological principle.

Closed Setting — Preferred for Jewellery

A closed setting means:

• The gemstone’s back is covered with metal
• No direct skin contact
• Focus on protection and design

Why Jewellery Uses Closed Settings

Closed settings are chosen for:

• Better protection
• Durability
• A refined aesthetic finish
• Comfortable daily wear

They are commonly used for ornamental pieces featuring:

• Diamond (Heera)
• Pearl (Moti)
• Red Coral (Moonga)
• Fashion-focused Ruby or Emerald jewellery

Here, beauty and craftsmanship matter more than astrological function.

Clear Separation of Purpose

Problems arise only when the two purposes are mixed.

Practical Clarifications

• Closed setting for astrology: Possible, but not ideal; it reduces direct contact
• Open setting for jewellery: Possible, but requires careful handling and is less durable

The Right Way to Decide

Ask one question:
Why am I wearing this gemstone?

• For astrology → Open setting
• For ornamentation → Closed setting

Do not force astrological rules onto jewelry design,
and do not expect jewellery design to serve astrological intent.

One-Line Summary

Open settings are preferred for astrological gemstones like Neelam, Pukhraj, Panna, and Manik due to direct skin contact, while closed settings are ideal for ornamental jewellery where protection and aesthetics come first.